Table of Contents
tabisuke
Presentation draft
About the speaker
A.k.a. Tabisuke Independent researcher Tokyo, Japan
Abstract
Table of contents
1. The essence of parliamentary principles Freedom ---- Efficiency (x) central control (o) autonomous distributed control
2. Examples of parliamentary rules – traditional / for wiki Motion Second Debate Vote
3. Vote A variety of votes – decision making Silence (no objection) Voice vote Majority vote Special majority vote Unanimous consent Low cost --- High cost Low importance -- important Who should be a voter ? Committer Everyone Those who are interested, e.g., those who edited the doc three times
4. Second What is the object of seconding ?
5. Motion Which motion first ?
6. Debate How to (effectively) debate ? Motion centered Pro/con switching Restrict frequent speech by one participant Visualize positions – pro/con/neither
7. Structuring policy debate and decision making Separate out facts and values (weighting/prioritizing) Pursuit consensus on facts Explicit confrontation and pursuit consensus on values Vote + Calculation
8. A wikiparliament “maturity model” Level 1: Introduce seconding for editing Level 2: Support drafting and publishing cycle with motion Level 3: Support voting Level 4: Support debating Level 5: Implement structural decision making
9. Debate ! Pro/con ? Suitable/unsuitable use case ? Modification ?